Welcome to the Law Office of Cavey & Barrett's Official Blog where you will find useful information about Florida Disability and Social Security Claims.
We care and make it a point to blog about the disabled and we are passionate about the issues that affect those who are applying or waiting for claims in Social Security Disability, Veterans' Disability Compensation, and Long-Term Disability Insurance benefits. We do our very best to blog about important topics such as advances in the various disability claims processes, advances in medicine, upgrades to the various disability benefits programs, anything to do with social security and other areas of disability.
Connect with Us! Contact us today or post a comment on one of our blogs.
Long Term Disability Attorney Richard Johnson appeared on Nicole Sandlers talk show on Air America discussing the effects that ERISA has on our clients. Nancy Cavey, a Florida based ERISA Long Term Disability attorney who handles cases in Florida, Georgia and Alabama suggests that you listen to this talk.
Nancy Cavey, a Long Term Disability ERISA lawyer who practices in Florida, has written two free consumer guides. Robbed of Your Peace of Mind and The Smart Long Term Disability Consumer Guide For Preparing For Your Statement and Field Visit, to help you understand terms you don’t want to see in your insurance policy and the games that Long Term Disability carriers play in denying your claim.
Long Term Disability carriers, like UNUM Life Insurance Company of America, frustrate those with fibromyalgia. It is important that you look at your Long Term Disability policy to determine whether or not there are any kinds of limitations on self reported conditions or a specific exclusion for Fibromyalgia. There also may be a limit for the payment of benefits for self-reported conditions of Fibromyalgia with a maximum of 24 months of benefits.
When filing for Long Term Disability benefits, your claim will be under surveillance and may have surprise visits from insurance carriers. Florida Long Term Disability attorney Nancy Cavey can help you with your claim.
When filing for a disability claim, you must repay the carriers claim first if you have Long Term Disability Benefits when you apply for Social Security disability as well.
In the L.A. Daily Journal, Evan George takes a look at California's disability insurance and finds that insurers wrongfully deny claims, despite findings by treating doctors and the federal goverment that they are too sick or hurt to hold a job.
The first in a two part series, the story shows that insurers create incentives for employees to turn down claims. Once denied, workers must navigate a complicated bureaucracy that takes years.
Of the cases that reach trial, judges found in nearly half the cases that the insurance companies had no legitimate reason to deny the claims. But because the injured workers can't sue for damages, there is no peril for the insurance companeis to repeatedly deny costly claims.
If you need a qualified disability insurance lawyer in Florida, please contact us at the Law Office of Cavey & Barrett for all your disability needs.
At Cavey & Barrett we are seeing a "slow pace strategy" by long-term disability carriers. We have found that carriers aren't "receiving paperwork," asking for the same information over and over, suggesting that they need information, indicating that there is a delay in getting information from physicians. These are all delay tactics that the long term disability carriers are using to delay payment to you.
With stock prices down and a lack of investment income earnings, disability insurance companies are taking longer to determine disability claims and to pay long-term disability benefits.
If you are experiencing any of these problems with your long-term disability or ERISA carrier, immediately contact Nancy Cavey at Cavey & Barret, a St. Petersburg disability insurance lawyer, to assist you in your long-term disability claim. There are things that can be done to expedite the handling of your long-term disability or ERISA claim. Remember, long-term disability insurance companies think that they can outlast long-term disability claimants. Our advice and counsel help you understand what your carrier is doing and help you prepare yourself financially.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
You may not have the protection for disability you thought you had when you bought your long term disability policy.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
Every medical professional should have a long term disability policy to protect themselves and their family if they became disabled. Do you know the 3 different types of long term policies or the advantages/ disadvantages of each. Nancy Cavey, a long term disability attorney who specializes in helping medical professionals with their disability claims, has written an article, "What Every Medical Professional Needs to Know about Disability Insurance"
Make sure that you have protected your income and standard of living!
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
Every medical professional should have a long term disability policy to protect themselves and their family if they became disabled. Do you know the 3 different types of long term policies or the advantages/ disadvantages of each. Nancy Cavey, a long term disability attorney who specializes in helping medical professionals with their disability claims, has written an article, "What Every Medical Professional Needs to Know about Disability Insurance"
Make sure that you have protected your income and standard of living!
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
(2) read the policy and the directions for filing their claim and follow every step;
(3) make a copy of everything you send to the disability carrier;
(4) send everything to the long term disability carrier with return receipt request to prove that you sent the material;
(5) if you speak with the adjuster, which Nancy Cavey does not suggest you do, document every telephone conversation;
(6) if you have a high monthly benefit policy, be prepared for surveillance. The disability insurance company will hire an investigator to videotape you;
(7) consider consulting Nancy Cavey to assist you through the disability claims application process. Nancy can assist you before you file, during, and after the claim has been filed;
(8) remember that disability insurance companies review files on an ongoing basis.
At Cavey & Barrett we are seeing a “slow pace strategy” and out right denial of valid claims by long-term disability carriers such as UNUM. This delay or denial is for the benefit of long term disability carrier. This aggressive claims handling has resulted in increased profits for UNUM. According to a UNUM Group Q1 2009 Earnings Call transript on May 4, 2009 "group disability earnings were 44% higher driven by strong risk results"... a fancy way of saying claims delay and denial .
With stock prices down and a lack of investment income earnings, disability insurance companies are taking longer to determine disability claims and to pay long-term disability benefits.
If you are experiencing any of these problems with your long-term disability or ERISA carrier, immediately contact Nancy Cavey at Cavey & Barrett to assist you in your long-term disability claim. There are things that can be done to expedite the handling of your long-term disability or ERISA claim. Remember, long-term disability insurance companies think that they can outlast long-term disability claimants. Our advice and counsel help you understand what your carrier is doing and help you prepare yourself financially.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
If you have any questions about how to prepare for this crucial event in your long term disability/ERISA claim, contact Tampa Bay attorney Nancy Cavey buy clicking the link or by calling 727-894-3188.
Your financial preplanning did not begin and end with the purchase a long-term disability policy. That was only the beginning!
You still have to make significant plans for your financial future. What do I mean?
If you suffer from a gradual onset disease like degenerative joint disease, Parkinson's disease, Lou Gehrig's disease, multiple sclerosis, or Alzheimer's, the disease process will give you the time you need to make significant work and financial decisions.
There are a number of steps that you must take, sooner and not later, in financial preplanning.
1. Learn about your disease and how it progresses over time.
It is important for you to understand how your disease will impact your ability to work, how it will progress over time, what your future medical needs are going to be, and when you will become unable to work.
The answers to these questions will impact how long you will be able to work and maintain any group insurance coverage.
2. Look at your current financial condition and determine how it might change over time.
This step requires a critical look at your current financial condition and obligations. What are your assets? Is there any disability coverage that would make the mortgage payment if you're unable to work or disability policies that would make payment on in the vehicles or consumer debt? How much do you owe? Do you have a budget?
How would that budget change if you become disabled? Can you get your finances under control in the time frame you have available to continue working? If not, how were you going to meet those obligations?
Do you know how long it takes to get Social Security disability benefits? When would you be entitled to Medicare? Can you afford to cobra your group insurance coverage? How long can you Cobra your group insurance? Is there going to be a gap in time between you running out of group health insurance coverage and be eligible for Medicare? Can you find alternative insurance?
3. Set financial goals.
These financial goals can be short-term or long-term. Do you have flexibility built in to these goals as your condition changes? How are you going to be able to live on a reduced income? How are you going to get medical treatment with reduced or limited medical benefits?
4. Obtaining assistance.
It is crucial that you understand what your long-term disability policy provides in the way of benefits, whether those benefits can be reduced by various offsets such as Social Security, how long you are entitled to benefits, what limitations may exist on coverage.
It is also crucial that you understand your rights to Social Security disability benefits and the amount of benefits you might be entitled to, including dependent benefits. Many states have a significant delay in getting a Social Security disability hearing. Your data eligibility for Medicare will depend on the date you become disabled for Social Security disability purposes.
It may be necessary for you to hire a long-term disability or Social Security disability Attorney and you can use this time to get answers to your questions. You may also have to consult with your insurance agent, tax advisor or financial planner.
5. Make flexible decisions.
As your disability progresses, your options will change, and you need to be prepared financially to address those changes. Having a game plan before your disability progresses gives you more control. Unfortunately, your options can become significantly limited if you fail to get advice before you become disabled. It's not uncommon that decisions become more typical as your disease progresses and your ability to make those decisions comes compromised.
Financial preplanning is a team effort, and one that should be done earlier and not later. Don't place yourself in a situation where you have to struggle to make difficult financial decisions in a time of need.
Experienced long-term disability/ERISA and Social Security attorney Nancy Cavey can provide guidance to you in the financial preplanning required as a result of your disability.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
Yes! I tell every long term disability/ERISA claim applicant that the long term/disabiity carrier will place surveillance on you. They will ask you to complete Activities of Daily Living forms and then try to catch you doing something you said you could not do. They will then confront you with the film and try to get you to sign a statement saying you are not telling the truth.
Disability Lawyer Nancy Cavey, based in St. Petersburg, can help you with your long term disability/ERISA claims application, preparing for your statement and denied claims.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
The long term disability/ERISA carrier may ask you to sign medical releases. Be careful because you do so at your own risk. The carrier will use that release to talk with your doctor about your medical condition and deny your claim for long term disability benefits.
The long term disability/ERISA carrier will also try to get your doctors to agree with their doctor's assessment about your ability to work or have them look at surveillance film. That will destroy your claim!
Don't give them access to your doctors by signing a medical release!
Read an article Virginia attorney Ben Glass wrote about signing insurance company releases.
If the long term disability/ERISA carrier insists sign a release call Nancy Cavey, an experienced long term disability/ERISA attorney, based in St. Petersburg Florida.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
If I want to hear real news, I listen to the BBC! The Guardian, a British newspaper, just published an article about America's ERISA statute urging Obama to support legislation that prohibits the use of discretionary clauses in ERISA policies. ERISA governs not only group health but disability plans.
ERISA group and long term disability carriers hide behind discretionary clauses in denying health claims. It is the same discretionary language long term disability/ERISA carriers use to deny ERISA disability claims.
Cavey and Barrett support legislation that prohibits allowing the carrier to hide behind a discretionary clause to justify their improper claims denials. These clauses make it very difficult for you to have your day in court and have an impartial decision about your entitlement to group health or long term disability benefits.
Way to go Guardian! Isn't amazing that Mr. Lazrus and Mr. Millihiser "get it" and not the Bush Administraton? Read this great article below:
"Rebalancing the scales of justice
Barack Obama must stop the supreme court from providing immunity to health insurers and other corporate law-breakers
Simon Lazarus and Ian Millhiser guardian.co.uk, Thursday November 13 2008 18.00 GMT Fourteen years ago, a single mother named Ann Dunham began a long, ultimately unsuccessful battle with cancer – and a simultaneous war with her health insurance provider. Over and over, as Ms Dunham's son, Barack Obama, recounted during the October 6 presidential debate, company representatives suggested that his mother's cancer "may have been a pre-existing condition and they don't have to pay her treatment".
Ann Dunham's story is hardly unique. Millions of Americans know well that the pain of serious illness is often compounded by endless jousts with insurers arbitrarily withholding coverage of physician-prescribed care. Myriad court records tell the stories of people like Maureen Kurtek, who lost five fingertips and most of her right foot after her husband's employer switched to an insurer which resisted continuing to cover her lupus treatment. And of construction manager James Lind, who was able to continue working despite his multiple sclerosis, until his insurer abruptly declined to continue paying for the prescription that had kept his MS at bay. And Rhonda Bast, who died after her insurer refused coverage of a bone marrow transplant which could have prevented her cancer from spreading to her brain.
Many of these sad stories could and should have been avoided. The fault lies with senior federal officials driven by the same deregulatory fervour responsible for enabling the imprudent lending frenzy behind the current financial crisis. In this case, however, the zealots do not run administrative agencies or departments. They preside at the United States supreme court. Over the past quarter-century, court majorities, led principally by Justice Antonin Scalia, have systematically dismantled the framework of laws designed to prevent benefit providers from breaking their promises to patients like Ann Dunham.
The keystone of this protective framework is the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, known by its acronym, Erisa. Congress passed Erisa in 1974 to protect the pensions and employer-provided health plans which millions of Americans rely upon. Yet the supreme court has twisted this law into something quite different. As noted by Senate judiciary chairman, Patrick Leahy, the court's perversion of Erisa is a prime example of decisions that have turned laws "on their heads, making them protections for big business rather than ordinary citizens."
Erisa sets strict standards to ensure that employers and insurers administering group benefit plans act "solely in the interests of beneficiaries for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits," not their own bottom-line. But the court has rendered these protections meaningless. In a Catch-22 decision written by Justice Scalia, a 5-4 majority held that, when plan administrators violate their obligations under the law, victims may not recover any monetary compensation for resulting losses they suffer. Adding insult to injury, the court has read Erisa as a warrant for "pre-empting" – ie abolishing – pre-existing state law protections, leaving victims with literally no recourse. Thus, in the words of, the late Justice Byron White, the supreme court has achieved the "perverse anomaly of leaving those Congress set out to protect with less protection than they enjoyed before Erisa was enacted."
When forced to apply the supreme court's "tangled" Erisa rules, ordinarily circumspect federal judges have often harshly attacked them. Most famously, the late Chief Judge Edward Becker, a Republican named to the third circuit court of appeals by President Reagan, excoriated Justice Scalia and his allies for converting Erisa "into a shield that insulates HMOs from liability for even the most egregious acts of dereliction committed against plan beneficiaries, a state of affairs directly contrary to the intent of Congress." Judge Becker stressed that the court's distortion of Erisa creates "strong incentives for HMOs to deny claims in bad faith or otherwise 'stiff' participants." The systemic result, he added, is a "'race to the bottom' in which the most profitable HMOs will be those that deny claims most frequently."
A recently discovered insurance company memo (pdf) confirms Judge Becker's insight. This smoking gun, an internal company directive, instructed claims processors to structure "new and existing policies" so as to ensure that they would be subject to Erisa. Once covered by this federal law originally hailed as a landmark safeguard for beneficiaries, the memo forecast, the company could eliminate over 90% of its payouts to claimants seeking redress for denials of coverage.
Immunity for health insurers is just one gift which the supreme court has given to powerful interests that find compliance with the law inconvenient. The most notorious recent example is the 2007 Ledbetter decision, in which the court's five conservatives held that victims of pay discrimination have only six short months to seek relief – even if they do not learn of the discrimination until years later. But the supreme court has also thwarted Congress' efforts to protect Americans with disabilities against discrimination (pdf). It has erected unprecedented barriers to patients seeking redress for unlawfully withheld Medicaid benefits, pre-empted state predatory lending (pdf) curbs, and extended lawsuit immunity to the manufacturers of dangerous medical devices. In case after case, the court has achieved de facto repeal of federal guarantees by eliminating citizens' ability to enforce them in court, and, through pre-emption, secured outright repeal of state law protections.
As the new president rolls out new proposals for ensuring health and economic security, he should not ignore the court's drive to roll back existing safeguards. If he acts fast, he could score some significant early wins, and send a clear signal that the new sheriff in town is serious about justice for ordinary citizens. Early in this Congressional term, it could be possible to legislatively "fix" decisions that distort major laws like Erisa and the Civil Rights Act equal pay guarantees upended in the Ledbetter case. His agency heads can rescind the mass of Bush administration regulations and policies that pre-empt vital state legal protections. His justice department can press the federal courts to faithfully construe laws in line with their original reformist purposes, and stop importing stealth deregulatory designs recently in vogue. Most important for the long-term, the president, together with allies in the Senate, can sensitise new judicial nominees to the priority of robust enforcement of guarantees protecting Americans' pocket book needs.
By targeting courts that coddle corporate law-breakers, President Obama can engineer change that will save millions of Americans from major financial, physical, and emotional travail."
Simon Lazarus and Ian Millhiser are attorneys with the National Senior Citizens Law Centre
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
Many long-term disability insurance policies require you to apply for Social Security disability benefits, and will offer the services of companies like Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc. to help you with your Social Disability Claim. Should you use these companies?
As an experienced long-term disability/ERISA and Social Security disability Attorney. My answer is unequivocally "No"!
In fact, UNUM was convicted on making LTD applicants apply for Social Security disability even if the applicant was not entitled to or qualified or eligible for Social Security disability.
Of course, some may think my answer is based on the fee I might earn on the Social Security disability claim. Nothing is further from the truth!
In my experience, most of these companies have non-attorney representatives handling the Social Security disability claim. The quality of this representation is suspect. I have had long-term disability cases where the company recommended by the long-term disability carrier did not develop the evidence properly before the Social Security administration. I have had other cases where the company recommended by long-term disability carrier has purposely developed a condition, such as fibromyalgia or psychiatric conditions, that only provide limited long-term disability benefits and have ignored proceeding on Social Security disability claims that could entitle the applicant to continued long-term disability benefits.
If you do get Social Security disability benefits, you are generally entitled to a retroactive lump sum payment. The long-term disability carrier's want their money back – immediately. Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc. will have you sign an agreement that allows them to automatically a withdrawal from your checking account any overpayment that might be due to your long-term disability insurance company. On the face of it, that's fair.
However, more often than not, long-term disability carrier's will immediately suspend the payment of your long-term disability benefits when you been awarded Social Security benefits saying that you are "no longer disabled" based on your long-term disability policy requirements.
As long as you keep the Social Security overpayment in your checking account, you and your long-term disability attorney will have greater leverage with a long-term disability insurance company to get your long-term disability benefits reinstated
Unfortunately, I find long-term disability carrier's use these companies for their own best interest. They want these companies to help you get Social Security disability benefits so that they can take back all the long term disability benefits that you've been paid, and then justify their immediate suspension of your long-term disability benefits. These companies will also share with your long-term disability carrier the medical reports they obtained or develop in your Social Security disability Claim. If they develop a bad report, you can be assured that report will get to your long-term disability carrier and be a basis for denial of your long-term disability claim.
Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc. will tell you if they work for you when, in fact, they get the referrals from a long-term disability carriers and get paid by the long-term disability carrier. They will use any agreement you sign to suck out of your checking account any Social Security benefits you get, and they will share a bad information about you with your long-term disability insurance company.
What should you do? If you have signed a contract with Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc, set a one sentence letter to the Social Security administration terminating their services. If you signed an authorization allowing Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc, to take money from your checking account, you need to revoke it immediately by writing to your bank and keeping a copy for your records. Send Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc a copy of that revocation by certified mail.
Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc may tell you that the long-term disability carrier won't include any attorney's fees paid to Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, Disability Services, Inc in any long-term disability overpayment calculations. There is anti-discrimination provisions in ERISA, so that if a long-term disability carrier pays a fee to any of these companies or reduces the overpayment by a Social Security attorney fee, it has to do the same thing if you hire a private Social Security disability Attorney. Don't be intimidated!
You should find an attorney who does both Social Security disability and long-term disability/ERISA litigation. Cavey and Barrett are experienced Social Security disability and long-term disability attorneys who coordinate the handling of both claims. We develop the necessary evidence needed in both Social Security disability and long-term disability claims.
If you can't find a lawyer who does both, make sure that your Social Security disability lawyer is coordinating his work with your long-term disability attorney. There are times when the Social Security disability lawyer can be working at cross purposes. For example, they may be developing a psychiatric aspect of your claim for Social Security purposes and be unaware that there is a limitation in your long-term disability policy for mental conditions.
Don't be taken advantage of by your long-term disability insurance company or Allsup, Occudanta, Advantage 2000, or Disability Services, Inc. Protect yourself by hiring experienced Tampa/St. Petersburg/Clearwater long-term disability/ERISA Social Security disability Attorney, such as Nancy Cavey.
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
2.5 Million American apply for Social Security disability benefits every year and it takes, on average a whopping 288 days, to get a decision on because of the backlog. The reality is that in the Tampa/St. Petersburg area the delay is almost 2 years.
What contributes to that delay? In an awesome article, the New York Times author, Mary Williams Walsch, exposed for the public what ERISA/LTD and Social Secuirty lawyers and their clients deal with every day. The Social Security Disability system is being clogged by long term diablility carriers, such as UNUM, Cigna, Liberty, who require any policy holder claiming long term disability benefits to apply for Social Security. And when a policy holder is denied, the long term disability carriers insist the policy holder appeal and appeal again!
The typical long term disability policy requires a policy holder to apply for Social Security Disability benefits. This improves the disability carrier's profit margin. If you refuse to apply, the long term disabiity carrier simply stops paying benefits until you apply or appeal. Sometimes, the long term disability carrier just reduces the long term disability payment by what you would have gotten in Social Security. This reduces the long term disability carrier's reserves and smaller reserves means bigger profits for the long carrier. So they pay less and can use their premium dollars for investment.
It gets worse. If you do get Social Security benefits, the long term disability wants thier money back from you lump sum retroactive Social Secuirty and reduce your monthly benefits! Then, many long term disability carriers have the gall to turn around after an award of Social Security benefits and tell their policy holder "They no longer qualify for LTD benefits.
Whistleblowers are claiming that since almost 18% of the long term disability applicants are ultimately denied Social Security, the long term disability carrier could screen those cases not likely to get Social security and not force their policy holder to apply and appeal.
Unloading unqualified Social Security applicants on the Social Security Administration's (SSA) doorstep is fraudulent and a waste of American tax dollars. Please read www.nytimes.com/2008/04/01/business/01disabled.
UNUM was recently convicted of falsely requiring UNUM long term disability policy holders collecting long term disability to apply for Social Security.
Your employer may have offered you a long term disability policy as part of your benefit package. Did you accept and begin paying premiums? If so, and if you are not employed by a church or a municipality, your claim is probably covered under the Empoyee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).
The ERISA Act was passed by Congress in 1974 to address teamster union corruption. Remember Jimmy Hoffa who used teamster dues to fund his criminal enterprise?
Congress wanted to pass a simple (not), comprehensive (not) and uniform (never) application of law for health, life, disability, and pension benefits plans. The ideas was to reduce litigation by having a uniform system that protected beneficiaires such as yourself while reducing premiums.
The reality is that ERISA, which impacts your health, life, disability insurance policies, and even your private penion or 401K plan, has failed miserably at meeting those goals.
ERISA has become a complicated regulatory maze that has only benefited administrators of ERISA plans and the insurance companies that offer these policies. ERISA has been used to deny people, like you, the benefits you paid for and the benefits you deserve.
ERISA specifically prohibits you from making any state law claims. Many state insurance laws provide consumer protection provisions such as prohibiting "discrectionary clauses" in policies.
ERISA usually presumes the claims administrator was right in making the decision to deny or limit your benefits. You, must show the claims administrator was "arbitrary and capricious" in denying your claim if you are going to win.
This is true even if the claims administrator who is making the decision to pay also pays the benefits. Talk about a conflict of interest!
Even if you proved you have been robbed, all you get are the benefits you asked for to begin with. You can't sue for compensatory damages or punative damages. You can't even ask that the claims administrator who wronfully denied your benefits be punished.
Even the court in Florence Nightingale Nursing Service v. Blue Cross Blue Shield, 832 F. Supp. 1456, 1457 (N.D.Al. 1993)called ERISA, "Everything Ridiculous Imagined Since Adam."
The United States Supreme Court heard oral argument on April 23, 2008 on the question of what deference a claims administrator should be given in an ERISA plan. This decision will have monumental impact on ERISA cases in the future.
The ERISA statute, 29 U.S.C. 1133(2) says that a person asking for payment of long term disability benefits should be given "full and fair review ... of the decision denying the claim." You also must be given "all documents, records, and other information relevant to the claimant's claim for benefis for a review to qualify as a full and fair review."
Doesn't that sound reasonable? Reality is different!
Ms Glazer, who had myofascial pain, fibomyalgia, cervical spodylosis and radiclopathy, was cut off by Reliance, based on the report of a notorious "peer review" doctor who always opines "there is no medical evidence" to support a continuing claim for disability benefits.
Ms. Glazer wanted, like you would want, to see the "peer review" report Reliance had produced while it was reviewing the initial denial of benefits. Reliance said "no!"
The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals has agreed with Reliance! The Court has ruled, in a circular fashion, that a "relevant document" is not relevant until Reliance relied on it to deny Ms. Glazer's claim. Only AFTER, Reliance relied on the peer review report and denied Ms. Glazer's claim, would Reliance have to produce the damining report of its peer review physician.
The 11th Circuit justified this by holding that if Reliance produced the peer review report (which it got for the sole purpose of denying Ms. Glazer's claim) earlier it would "create an unnecessary cycle of submission, review, resubmission, and re-review."
I don't disagree but let's remember that Reliance started this review for the sole purpose of terminating Ms. Glazer's benefits. There was nothing fair about the process and letting Reliance hide this report during the review of the initial denial forces claimants like Ms. Glazer to try to "put the horse back in the barn."
Answering these broad-based questions isn't easy. Help is a phone call away. You can contact Nancy Cavey, an experienced long-term disability attorney at 727-894-3188.
We represent clients all over Florida including: Tampa, St. Petersburg, Sarasota, Bradenton, Venice, Ft. Myers, Naples, Orlando, Lakeland, Gainesville, Daytona, West Palm Beach, Ft. Lauderdale, Miami, Miami Beach, Jacksonville, Tallahassee, New Port Richey, Hudson, Safety Harbor, Largo, Palm Harbor, Port Richey, Clearwater, Indian Rocks Beach, Dunedin, Spring Hill, Brooksville, and all other cities in Florida.
If you or someone you know has been effected by a hour and wage claim, disability or social security claim in Florida, do not hesitate to Contact Us before you speak with an insurance company. There is no obligation to hire a lawyer and the consultation is FREE.